How to avoid capital gains tax
Hi Sir/Madam
Me and my brother sold a property in April last year(2014). Now I have heard that one must declare in the IT return this year. I have been looking to buy a property since last year; however have not finalised it yet.
Do I need to put that money in the Capital Gains account to avoid any tax on it or just leave it in the savings account where it is already as I should be able to finalise on the property this year?
Please help.
Regards
Sharma
Asked 9 years ago in Capital Gains Tax
The capital gain arising may be saved if the person in whose hand capital gain tax is chargeable purchases a residential flat within 1 year before the transfer or 2 years after the date of such transfer . If he wants to construct the new residential house it can be done within a period of 3 years after the date of such transfer . Further the law allows to park the proceeds in a separate account till than it has been so used .
For doing all the above , you must show the transfer and the capital gain arising therefrom on the ITR and then claim relief under various subsection of section 54 .
In case of ITR , it can be revised , provided if you have time to park the fund in the designated account .
CA, New Delhi Area, India
120 Answers
20 Consultations
Thank you Mr. Sinha. There is one more question here if you could answer please. We inherited this property last year-2014 from our mother who died a year before and sold it in the same year-2014. As per the computation of capital gain based on cost inflation index, if we consider the acquisition year as year of purchase, which is in our case would be the same year as year of sale i.e. 2014, there should not be any tax liability.
Is the above correct in this inheritance case or do we need to take the actual year of purchase(when my mother bought the property) into consideration and put that gain amount in the capital gain account until we finalise the property?
Asked 9 years ago
You have to deposit capital gains in capital gains account with any scheduled bank on or before last date of filing of Income tax return for asst year 2015-16 to claim exemption u/s 54 of I T Act.
CA, Hyderabad
248 Answers
13 Consultations
There is a difference between inheritance and acquisition. In your case since you have inherited property in 2014, the relevant year for determining capital gains is actual date of purchase by your mother or by whomsoever as the case may be.
CA, Hyderabad
248 Answers
13 Consultations
Hi Sharmaji
You need to deposit the amount in capital gain within 6 months. Now you cannot deposit the amount in capital gain account scheme and claim exemption. You cannot leave the same in Savings account.
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
In the other query the cost to the previous owner will be the cost of acquisition i.e. cost on which it was acquired.
Also the year in which it was acquired by your mother will be taken as year of acquisition for long term capital gain purpose. You can put that amount in capital gain account within 6 months.
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
Hello Mr. Modani....Thank you for your opinion. Referring to Mr. Kale's comment above that I can put the money in the capital gain account on or before the return date, my question is that are you disagreeing with what he is saying? I also read on certain websites that one has to put the money in 6 months but if that is missed it can be put before the return file as well.
If thats the case, can I put the money in the capital gain account on or before 31st Aug 2015(revised return file date)?
Also, one more thing if I manage to buy the property with this money before the 31st Aug, will I get an exemption?
Thank you.
Asked 9 years ago
Hi Sharmaji
I agree with Mr. Sinhaji, You can deposit the amount before the filing of returns or before due date i.e. 31st August 2015.
I thought that you are asking for investment in Bonds which date is within 6 months. Sorry for the confusion.
first of all whether you have filed your original return for A.Y.2015-16 or not, since you have written revise return file date.
Yes you can get exemption if you manage to buy property within 31st August. But first let me know whether you have filed original return or not.
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
No I have not filed the original return yet. But I am sure I have still got time to file as I the date has been extended. Please clarify. And can I deposit the money in capital gain next month as well if not this month but before 31st Aug. Is SBI Bank for that?
Thank you for your support.
Asked 9 years ago
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
You can get exemption u/s 54 and 54F, if you invest in a residential house, u/s 54EC if you invest in capital gains bonds. If you have not invested in acquisition of a residential house u/s 54F, the amount should be deposited in capital gains account before the due date for filing your return of income, i.e., 31st August 2015 in your case.
As the property sold by you is inherited from your mother, her cost of acquisition will be the cost of acquisition for you also.
CA, Hyderabad
1018 Answers
124 Consultations
It is good compliance if money is deposited in capital gains accounts scheme on or before 31-08-2015 being last date notified for filing of return of Income as of now. There is no such thing as within six months and then before last date which is not correct.
Further if you invest capital gains in the new house property on or before last date i e 31-08-2015 then you can claim exemption of capital gains u/s 54 to the extent of cost of the new asset.
CA, Hyderabad
248 Answers
13 Consultations
you can deposit the money with SBI in capital gains account scheme account.
CA, Hyderabad
248 Answers
13 Consultations
Thank you Mr. Kale for your answer. It really helps. There are last two questions if you could help me with please:
1. The sale amount was shared between we two brothers equally as we were joint owners of the property. So I am hoping the capital gain after the calculation will have to be shared between two of us equally. are there any clauses in a joint owner ship?
2. There were different views from the executives in SBI when I went to open an account yesterday on withdrawal of the amount when its needed. One person was saying that it will be a straight forward procedure and the cheque/draft will be issued in the name of seller only and not me when I buy the property which is understandable. The other person is saying it will have to be in seller's name only but I will hve to get it approved by some Income tax officer/Authority first to get it processed. I am confused now whether to put the money or not.
Please help.
Asked 9 years ago
Yes the capital gains need to be shared between both brothers.
As per the Act, you need to get Income Tax clearance certificate from Income Tax Department for withdrawl of money from the Capital Gains Account Scheme. There are different views of different Banks. Some permit you to withdraw amount as per yours words, some ask for certificate and some ask for documentary proof of investing in other Property.
It is not easy to get certificate from Income Tax Department.
Actually SBI and some other Banks are asking for the certificate, but other Banks are permitting you to withdraw money.
Thus we suggest you to deposit in a Bank which is known to you.
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
Thank you Mr. Modani. I opened the capital gain account with SBI yesterday with the minimum amount and have not transferred the sale money yet.
The branch manager at SBI branch said it will not require the certificate and one of the other senior staff said it will be required. It was very confusing and its only been said verbally so I dont know who is right or wrong.
Could you please suggest which other bank would not ask for the income tax certificate? I do not have any other accounts with any nationalised banks and I know only nationalised banks offer the capital gain account.
I really appreciate your support so far....
Asked 9 years ago
Yes nationalised Banks only offer capital gains scheme.
See there is no possibility that the person in the Bank will be same when you withdraw.
I do in Syndicate Bank in Hyderabad. It all depends upon your relation with Banker. No problem you can go ahead with SBI in which you have opened Account. At that time you can manage.
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
Thank you Mr. Modani. In a worst case scenario, how long can it take to get the Income tax certificate? Also, do I have an option of opening another capital gain account with some other bank where they assure me of hastle free withdrawal. In that case, can I keep the other account with SBI or close it?
Asked 9 years ago
No one can assure you of the same as it depends on Officer to officer and Bank to Bank.
You can get the IT Clearance certificate if having good rapport with Department in a weeks time as per my view.
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
Its a question addressed to CA Modani.
CA, Hyderabad
1018 Answers
124 Consultations
The law is very clear, the banks are appointed here to supervise the utilisation of money kept for purchase/construction of residential house property. It is incorrect that every time you withdraw you require certificate from income tax officer. It is only at the last withdrawal you have to obtain certificate from Income tax officer. It is true that the withdrawal is for the purpose giving money to seller of a house in case of purchase and land and construction expenses are paid to respective vendors and bankers cheque will be given in the name of concerned vendor . If you are confident that money will be used for acquisition of a residential house, then you need not be worried, only you have to fill up the form given by bank indicating the name of the party and purpose of the payment, and the bank or the income tax officer has no role in such payment.
CA, Hyderabad
248 Answers
13 Consultations
Thanks Mr. Kale. I know that the money will be withdrawan one time only for the purpose of buying a property.
Referring to your comment that at the last withdrawal(or first and last in my case), will I still need to obtain a certificate? I hope not. And that's the confusion I still have. I have still not transferred the money yet.
Please advise.
Asked 9 years ago
You are referring to Mr. Kale, Thus i think the question is for him.
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
Its a question addressed to CA Kale.
CA, Hyderabad
1018 Answers
124 Consultations
Hello respected CA's.. I dont mind answer from anyone. In addition to the above, can I ask another question please. Does the amount of capital gain need to be absolutely precise to be put into the capital gain account or can it be approx. for e.g. if its 20.80 lakhs, can 21 Lakh be put into the account?
Asked 9 years ago
You can deposit even more.
CA, Hyderabad
1018 Answers
124 Consultations
Dear
You can deposit more than the gain amount, no problem. You can put 21 Lakhs also
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
Yes you need to obtain certificate from Income Tax Officer even if it is only one withdrawal. Why are you afraid of going to Income tax officer.
CA, Hyderabad
248 Answers
13 Consultations
The quantum of exemption is proportional to amount invested by you so it is not the preciseness of amount, but you can calculate quantum of capital gains with fair amount of certainty, then why you can not invest the precise amount derived by you.
CA, Hyderabad
248 Answers
13 Consultations
Thank you Mr. Kale. I am not afraid of going to the income tax officer :). I am concerned about the hastle and time it could take. One of the officers in SBI told me that it can be a real pain; hence I put this question in this forum. By the way, where do I actually go to see the income tax officer? I live in Noida so will it be in Delhi or in noida itself?
I wanted to put the round figure in the account; hence I asked this question of depositing into the capital gain account.
Asked 9 years ago
Is looks this question for Mr. Kale as it is in reply to some answer given by Mr. Kale in his Mail
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
Anyone could answer if its ok please....
Asked 9 years ago
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
You have to file an application with the Income tax officer, having jurisdiction over your case. Since you are living in noida, you have to contact office in Noida and get the authorization from him to withdraw the money to issue cheque in favour of concerned seller. It should not take more than 30 days to get permission from the officer. The round figure can be nearest hundred over capital gain amount.
CA, Hyderabad
248 Answers
13 Consultations
Thank you Mr. Kale. Yo had mentioned in one of yours above that the bank and income tax officer will not have any role in the withdrawal. thats the reason I wanted to clarify with others as well. I am 100% confident that the money will have to be taken out for the property only and nothing else.
Regards
Sharma
Asked 9 years ago
CA, Hyderabad
248 Answers
13 Consultations
Thank you Mr. Kale. Looks like I might finalise the property in the next week or two weeks. But as you know that the whole property transaction takes around 1-2 months, can I ask you if its fine to put the money in the capital gain account since the return dat of 31st Aug is approaching and then take the money out for the new property sale.
Or do not put the money in the capital gain account as likelihood of signing a deal with an initial amount in the next 10 days is high.
Sorry to be a pain, but this is my current situation.
Thank you.
Asked 9 years ago
Its a query addressed to CA Kale.
CA, Hyderabad
1018 Answers
124 Consultations
You can also answer Mr. Kale please if its ok....
Asked 9 years ago
Sorry Mr. Kumar....
Asked 9 years ago
message to be forwarded to Mr. Kale sir on his personal ID
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
If you wish to avail to exemption u/ 54 then you must deposit the money in capital gain accounts scheme.
CA, Hyderabad
248 Answers
13 Consultations
Its a query addressed to other CA?
CA, Hyderabad
1018 Answers
124 Consultations
Hello Gentlemen. I have put themoney in capital gain account. Do I need to submit ITR1 & ITR2 together or ITR2 only to show my salary income & capital gain in my Income tax return.
Also, is there any minimum amount for which you have to declare the capital gain or its any amount. In my case its just less than Rs. 25 Lakhs. I read somewhere about 50 lakhs or something so I am confused.
Please help.
Thank you.
Asked 9 years ago
You need to submit ITR 2. There is no minimum amount, you need to declare all.
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
CA, Hyderabad
1409 Answers
164 Consultations
you will have to submit return of income in ITR 2.
CA, Hyderabad
248 Answers
13 Consultations
You need to submit only ITR 2 - you cannot submit two ITRs. Go for e-filing with the help of a CA to avoid errors.
You can invest the amount of Rs 21 L as already advised.
CA, Hyderabad
1018 Answers
124 Consultations